Tub-to-Shower Conversions · Statewide

Should I Replace My Bathtub With a Walk-In Shower?

A practical way to decide — who benefits from a walk-in shower, when keeping a tub makes sense, and what to plan for either way.

BathPeak Editorial Team· Reviewed by Moe Moustafa, Founder of BathPeakUpdated October 1, 20265 min read

Key takeaways

  • If nobody in the home uses the tub and stepping over it is getting harder, a walk-in shower is usually the better daily bathroom.
  • Keep a tub somewhere if you bathe young children or love soaking.
  • Plan for future needs during the conversion — it costs less now than later.

The short answer

Replace the tub if it mostly serves as a shower you have to climb into. Keep it if someone actually bathes in it, or if it is the only tub in a home where young children live. Many households get the best of both by converting one bathroom and leaving a tub in another.

A walk-in shower usually makes sense when

  • Stepping over a tub wall is uncomfortable or unsafe for someone in the home.
  • You plan to stay in the house as you age.
  • The tub is used once or twice a year.
  • You want a larger, easier-to-clean shower in the same space.

Keep the tub when

  • It is the only tub and you bathe small children or pets.
  • Soaking is part of your routine.
  • You plan to sell soon and buyers in your area expect at least one tub — ask a local real estate agent.

BathPeak insight: plan for later now

During a conversion the walls are open. That is the cheapest moment to add blocking for future grab bars, a handheld shower on a slide bar and a bench. Even if nobody needs them today, adding them later means opening finished walls.

Next steps

If this guide matches your plans, our page on tub-to-shower conversions explains scope, pricing and what to expect. Homeowners near Greensboro can also read about tub-to-shower conversions in Greensboro. Ready to price your own bathroom? Book a free in-home consultation.

← Back to all BathPeak remodeling guides

Frequently asked questions

About the author

BathPeak Editorial Team — Bathroom remodeling writers

The BathPeak editorial team writes our cost, planning and accessibility guides using the pricing, scheduling and installation details our own bathroom remodeling crews work with every day in North Carolina.

Reviewed for accuracy by Moe Moustafa, Founder of BathPeak.

Get a written price for your bathroom

Free in-home consultation, package quote with the full scope of work, no pressure. Prefer to talk it through? Call (336) 300-2524

Fully insured in NCRemodeling roots since 202230+ years combined install experience
  1. Step 1: Project
  2. Step 2: Location
  3. Step 3: Timing
  4. Step 4: Investment
  5. Step 5: Contact

Step 1 of 5 · Project

What are you interested in?

Fully insured in NCRemodeling roots since 202230+ years combined install experience
Prefer to talk? Call (336) 300-2524
Call Now